Annex E — Qualitative comparison of the candidate architectures
Annex 5 of 17 · ≈ 1 min read · 1 paragraphs · section 27 of 40 · search the book
This annex presents a provisional multi-criteria comparison of four candidate architectures. It is an initial author’s pre-test, not an independent evaluation: its weightings are declared and its scores are illustrative. It is presented here so that the body of the text may advance the argument without giving the impression that it is itself rating its own design; an external rating exercise is identified as future work.¶ 1
The table is wider than the screen: drag it sideways.
| Candidate | Exhaustiveness | Separation | Consent | Contestation | Implementation | Capture | Economy | Containment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Three integrated bodies | medium-strong | limited | medium | medium | medium-strong | limited | strong | limited |
| Five-body architecture | strong | medium | medium | medium-strong | medium | medium | medium | medium |
| Seven institutions + three instruments | strong | strong | medium | strong | medium | medium | limited | strong |
| Orchestration by incumbents alone | medium | limited | medium | limited | strong | limited | strong | medium |
Cite this section
Yaïche, Nizar (2026). Annex E — Qualitative comparison of the candidate architectures. In The Humanity Compact (v2.3). Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22746533
@incollection{yaiche_hc_annexe_e,
author = {Yaïche, Nizar},
title = {Annex E — Qualitative comparison of the candidate architectures},
booktitle = {The Humanity Compact},
year = {2026},
version = {2.3},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22746533},
publisher = {Zenodo},
url = {https://humanitycompact.org/ouvrage/annexe-e/}
}A book by Nizar Yaïche, former Minister of Finance of the Republic of Tunisia. Who is the author?